Haunting on Centre Street

Banner photo is Centre St, north from Christopher St, in 1907.  Courtesy of Toronto Public Library.

In keeping with the Halloween spirit, I have a terrifying tale of old Toronto for you.  You may want to turn down the lights for this one.  But don’t worry, I’m right here if it gets too scary.

On February 11th, 1884, the Toronto Daily Mail printed – in all seriousness – a family’s terrifying account of living in, what could only be, a haunted house.  Let’s take a look:

Ghost or Goblins Part 1 larger

Oh dear, this doesn’t bode well.  Not only is it possible we’re dealing with ghosts or goblins, but someone has also mysteriously discovered blood.  As opposed to, say, discovering mysterious blood.

Ghosts or Goblins part 2

So these two Irish families, the Wallaces and the Hannas, take up residence together at 120  Centre St and all sorts of shenanigans start happening.  And though they are respectable and intelligent, never before believing in silly ghost stories, they now just don’t know what to think.  Whereas you might be thinking “Centre St?”

Now called Centre Ave, it is a fairly short street that runs north from Osgoode to Edward – one block east of University – though it once stretched almost to College.   When the Wallaces and Hannas lived there their little home happened to be at the NW corner of Centre and … Elm St.

Here we see a stretch of Centre St. six years after the haunting, though I imagine it hadn't changed much. And frankly, it looks spooky as all get-out to me.
Here we see a stretch of Centre St, near Elm, six years after the haunting. Frankly, it looks spooky as all get-out to me.  Courtesy of Toronto Public Library.

Of course it’s not until after they move in and start being terrorized that all the helpful neighbours and friends come forth and say “Oh jeez, we didn’t know you were moving into that house … coulda told you it was haunted.”

So what kind of things were going on in the house?

Ghosts or Goblins part 3

Ugh.  Cold dread – that’s what I’d have felt if I was poor Mrs. Wallace waiting as someone or “spirit sans body” climbed the stairs.

Ghosts or Goblins 4

I’ve never connected a heavy tread with being in stocking feet, but who am I to say.  At least things appear to have calmed downed on Centre St.  … or had they?

Ghosts or Goblins 6

Poor Wallace is polite enough to open the door for the, uh, thing and gets a sleepless night for his troubles.

Ghosts or Goblins 7

Now that we’ve heard about the blood, it seems less like a portentous event and more like a “huh, how’d that get here” moment.   But the flying knife and the banging pot?  I’d be out of there faster than you could say “Is it likely we have goblins in Toronto?”

As for the Wallaces and Hannas, they most certainly did move out soon after these events. And, interestingly enough, the next recorded resident of 120 Centre St was a Mr. Bates …

Today, the stretch of Centre St where the troubled house sat is gone – lopped off long ago and replaced by the Hospital for Sick Children.  As for the meddlesome spirits, who knows – but I for one wouldn’t dawdle in the bowels of the hospital.

6 thoughts on “Haunting on Centre Street

  1. Haha, I love how they seemed relatively unconcerned about a random pool of blood. Only that no one could have gotten in and left the blood without her noticing, rather than that one of her family members could have potentially been bleeding enough to create a large puddle. My favourite ghost is probably still Scratching Fanny of Cock Lane, because of the name alone, but I love the nonchalant tone the newspaper relates this story in (and your commentary!).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ha! I know, her lack of familial concern really cracked me up too. So glad you enjoyed it! I’m going to have to read up on your Scratching Fanny (sorry, that’s bad phrasing) – I can definitely do with more good ghost stories.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s